outstanding_human_review

Bulk v1 — Remaining Human Semantic Review

Final outstanding formalization queue after deterministic reconciliation and materialization.

Status

• Formal revisions persisted: 1,683 / 1,702
• Outstanding revisions: 19
• Evidence blockers: 0
• New bulk review decisions: 0
• Production eligible claims remain: 39

The 19 rows below are intentionally not auto-revalidated. Each requires a semantic or ontology decision that cannot be proven from wikilink drift alone.

1. ICMS / CMX ontology and rebrand — 14

The source describes the platform historically as ICMS / Inference Context Memory Storage and later under CMX branding. The existing Inference Context Memory Storage canonical node remains meaningful, while there is no safe automatic rule establishing whether CMX is merely an alias, a renamed canonical identity, or a successor/new node.

Legacy ID	Source line	Human decision
NIEK2-0291	365	Decide ICMS canonical + CMX alias vs CMX successor/new canonical vs explicit rebrand relation.
NIEK2-0292	365	Same ontology decision.
NIEK2-0303	377	Resolve ICMS/CMX identity before changing the frame target.
NIEK2-0319	391	Resolve ICMS/CMX identity before removing the historical target.
VR2-0221	321	Decide the canonical identity and rebrand relationship.
VR2-0222	321	Decide whether ICMS remains, CMX replaces it, or both are represented.
VR2-0231	325	Resolve ICMS/CMX ontology before formalization.
VR2-0232	325	Resolve alias vs successor/new canonical vs rebrand relation.
VR2-0234	327	Resolve which canonical node represents the platform after rebranding.
VR2-0243	331	Resolve platform identity before formalizing provider ecosystem relation.
VR2-0244	331	Same provider-ecosystem ontology decision.
VR2-0245	331	Same provider-ecosystem ontology decision.
VR2-0246	331	Same provider-ecosystem ontology decision.
VR2-0247	331	Same provider-ecosystem ontology decision.

2. Ambiguous bare Vera reference — 4

These rows previously targeted NVIDIA Vera CPU, but the current source no longer retains an explicit Vera CPU surface form. Bare Vera is not sufficiently specific for a fail-closed automatic mapping.

Legacy ID	Source line	Human decision
VR2-0119	149	Confirm whether bare Vera means the canonical NVIDIA Vera CPU.
VR2-0199	295	Confirm whether the implicit Vera reference is specifically NVIDIA Vera CPU.
VR2-0200	295	Same identity check.
VR2-0201	295	Same identity check.

3. Multi-target alias drift — 1

Legacy ID	Source line	Human decision
VR2-0609	733	Independently confirm both NVIDIA Vera CPU and Vera Rubin frame participants; the current evidence loses both specific links while adding generic CPU.

Already formalized Golden rows still visible as non-ready in corpus preflight

These are not part of the 19 outstanding revision slots because a Golden/repair revision already exists:

• NIEK2-0054
• NIEK2-0215
• VR2-0242
• VR2-0504

Review rule

Do not convert any of the 19 rows to READY solely because the raw text still resembles the prior claim. A reviewer must explicitly resolve the ontology/entity identity first; any accepted repair should remain source/hash-bound and must not create an APPROVE decision automatically.